Pirates are not hackers and software piracy is also the Government’s fault

In January 2011 Italian newspaper Repubblica published an article that is a nice example of how much confusion there still is, in mainstream press, about the nature of software and copyright, their relevance for all citizens and the responsibilities of Public Administrations in these fields. That article may have been written everywhere, there’s nothing specifically Italian in it, so I translated my objections to it because they too may be useful outside Italy (to stimulate discussion if nothing else).

The article titled Il Bel Paese dei pirati – siamo un popolo di hacker (translation: “The beautiful country of pirates – we are a people of hackers”) shows its poor quality and attitude before even reading it, from its very title.

The message that the title sends is that software pirate (used in the original article as synonymous of “computer criminal”) = hacker. Usage of this equation has been for many years a sure way to assess the (in)competence and the conscious or unconscious agenda of whoever writes about Information and Communication Technology. A software pirate, or computer criminal, is a person that commits some computer-related crime, something that is against the law and can be only done with a computer. A hacker is a completely different person, instead. A hacker is a person that can’t avoid to tinker with some technology (software, as far as we are concerned). A person that really wants to study how stuff works and how to improve or customize it: what’s wrong, or illegal, about this? Saying or encouraging people to think that “computer criminal = hacker” you send the message that being a hacker is against the law, or at least something socially untolerable, not unlike smoking in a closed room where there are also children and pregnant women. Why?

Going past the title, half that article simply repeats for free, acritically accepting it as being as true as the Gospel, only one voice: the heart-breaking, tearful declarations of who, like the Italian anti-audio/video piracy Federation (FAPAV), wants to maintain their current monopoly on music and movies distribution:

[according to]…a terrible estimate in a recent study of Tera Consultants about content piracy through physical copies and Internet downloads… the creative industries of the European Union may suffer, from here to 2015, losses as high as 240 billions of Euros and 1.2 millions of jobs”

The truth is that, even if copyright should be respected, whoever wants to report about these matters should first try to understand for real how big the actual damage is and who really suffers from it, rather than blindly repeat numbers provided by one, pathetically not neutral stakeholder. There are lots of studies that tell the other side of the story, like (pages in italian) this from Scambio Etico or this from NBTimes.

The article goes on by repeating the same mistake made in the title: “the diffusion of broadband substantially changed the scenario, driving an exponential growth of downloads and Internet piracy”. It will be interesting to see what Nichi Vendola, a likely adversary of Berlusconi at the next general elections, thinks about this position, since he publicly promotes universal broadband as a panacea, even when he only does it to take the discussion away from Free Software, but this is another story. The problem of that sentence is that it contains the implicit equation downloading = piracy, whereas downloading stuff from the Internet is not always illegal. This must always be very clear, to fight the misinformation that’s always around, even in official initiatives. Two perfect Italian examples of what I mean are the partnership between Google and the Italian Telecom Police or the EMCA propaganda inside Italian Schools.

What about software?

After explaining how illegal downloads of music and movies will do much more damage than global warming, that article moves to software:

“even software is heavily damaged by online piracy, as stressed by the IDC study commissioned by the Business Software Alliance (BSA): data show that software piracy is increased worldwide… In the European Scenario, piracy amounts to 57% of the Italian market, putting our country at the first place in Europe, together with Greece”

too bad that the author doesn’t mention all cases in which businesses and families are forced, or at least encouraged, obviously not in an explicit way, to use pirated, that is illegally installed software, by Public Institutions of all sorts, from public schools to political parties. For example:

In addition to the story of a few big companies, the article author should have told also the huge economic damage for ALL businesses, families, schools and Public Administrations that would result from paying licenses for software that is not really needed! With a crisis like the current one, many families and small businesses certainly have no money left to buy expensive software. That would not be a problem, since there so much Free Software that is perfectly adequate to their real needs. Or, more exactly, that would not be a problem if those users were not forced to use certain specific programs, only because some customer won’t pay or some teacher won’t give good grades if they don’t get their files in the format that they demand simply out of laziness or ignorance. So why not say that, at least for certain software programs, piracy is an obligation created from the top, by demanding or tolerating proprietary formats in public contexts, even when there is no real need for them?

Summing up, this article from Repubblica, or any other of the same type, has only one value: it demonstrates once more that, copying and downloading everything one finds even when there is no actual need for it (haven’t you ever meet people, especially young ones, whose computer is full of movies, songs and other files they have never opened?) it’s a huge help to multinationals. Because it gives them numbers to justify certain assertions and give credibility to absurd law proposals like computer health certificates or cash for software clunkers. Please remember this, before doing illegal downloads from the Internet. Above all, remember to ask your representatives and all your local Public Administrations to demand that only truly open digital formats are used for public documents.


8 thoughts on “Pirates are not hackers and software piracy is also the Government’s fault

  1. Pingback: Software is too important to leave it to programmers | Stop

  2. Pingback: Linux News » Pirates are not hackers and software piracy is also the Government’s fault

  3. Pingback: Links 19/2/2011: Ubuntu 10.04.2 LTS is Out, Android/Linux is Beating Apple | Techrights

  4. Carl Kreider

    You certainly get it!
    >haven’t you ever meet people, especially young ones, whose computer is full of movies, songs and other files they have never opened?

    I certainly have, ever since the start of the personal computer age. And most of the people who actually use stolen software (eg Windows in Eastern Europe) would not buy it if they could not download a cracked copy because they can not afford it.

  5. IceTheNet

    Much smoking of good drugs is the cause of writing like this. A hacker maybe good maybe bad. There are both categories not all hackers are angels and not all angels are hackers LOL. But more to the point if your just downloading music and movies then perhaps you would be better categorized as a normal user than a pirate. as those that listen to radio or watch TV are called audience. A pirate is a person who would board a watercraft and attempt to or take over operation of said watercraft. People who download movies are not often adorned with Eye Patches, Peg Legs or Hook Arms.

    Because MPAA RIAA and the like have failed to provide quality downloads with advertising built into those downloads so they make there “Unfair Share” is no reason to call their clients PIRATES or HACKERS. There main problem is and has been the economy suffering loss of profit due to a person’s ability to barely pay their mortgage and eat. Entertainment cost’s are the first thing to go. So it is fairly obvious over the past 10 years of economic downturn that the entertainment industry would suffer the most.

    as far as banks, IAG, Auto Corps and Wall Street have all felt the crushing blow of this economy why should the music and movie business be any different. Do they feel that they are somehow recession proof. In either case it is just bad business to bit the hand that feed’s you and they have brought on there downfall. This is where Hackers Come to play. Now they brought us in on the play and they think they can win us. They are dead wrong. When the economy get’s good again they will then truly start to suffer losses untold. Because they chose to spend there money to harass their customers rather than embrace the technology. They in the end will loose.

    Hackers are people who tend to equal the playing field against those that practice bad business. The more they try to resist the more hackers provide quality hacked material as if driven like sharks by the fury of their rivals. like Microsoft and the WGA this has never been successful and the DRM this has been defeated to the point were Microsoft has decided to drop WGA on Office probably soon will on Software and The DRM is fading soon to be a thing of the past. And there attempt at Torrent engines has met with very little if no effect costing them billions of dollars with no solid gain. if one shuts down two more will open. If they get to nosy on the BT Software one hacker will find a way to defeat that and when they develop secure BT then there will be no more resources for these Stupid Men to follow.

    Hackers have always won these stupid battles and they always will. They may think that they have one by jailing a single one of them like Kevin Mitnick. There are literally millions of us all over the world and some get paid from their government to do precisely this type of job. Many will go noticed and are very good at what they do. Some maybe seen and chased but never caught. Some are evil and damned destructive and have no good intent but to break into your computer to obtain information or delete your stuff.

    To create and plant viruses and malware usually for corporations like Symantec or McAfee Inc. and although hackers are not pirates( ;) LOL ) they usually enjoy a good movie now and then. as for me I just don’t have time and I don’t care I am to busy coding and searching and doing things on a computer that most people would never have the ability to do. That is what a true hacker is.

  6. Pingback: Does VODAFONE really ignore how copyright works? Why? | Stop

  7. Pingback: פיראטים אינם האקרים | הקובץ

  8. Pingback: Of Vodafone, Copyright, Fair Use and Italy | Stop

Comments are closed.